When it comes to choosing the right suitcase, travelers want reliability, durability, and value for money. Best and Worst Luggage Brands on Reddit discussions reveal real user experiences, highlighting brands that stand the test of time—and those that don’t.
Luggage quality is more than just looks; it affects your travel experience. A broken zipper, weak wheels, or fragile material can turn a smooth trip into a hassle. That’s why seasoned travelers rely on firsthand reviews to find brands that offer durability, smart design, and airline-friendly features.
This guide dives into the best and worst luggage brands, as ranked by Reddit users. We’ll explore factors like material quality, size, and whether airlines prefer hard or soft luggage. Plus, we’ll discuss how to spot a suitcase that will last—and which ones to avoid. Whether you’re a frequent flyer or a casual traveler, this guide will help you make a smart luggage investment.
Best Luggage Brands According to Reddit
When it comes to finding high-quality luggage, travelers on Reddit consistently praise a few standout brands. These brands are known for their durability, well-designed features, and excellent customer service.
1. Samsonite
A long-time favorite, Samsonite is widely regarded as one of the best luggage brands. It offers a balance of affordability and durability, making it a top choice for frequent travelers. Many Reddit users highlight the brand’s sturdy wheels, strong zippers, and lightweight design. Samsonite’s warranty and customer service also receive positive feedback, ensuring peace of mind for buyers.
2. Away
Away has gained a loyal following for its sleek, modern designs and durable polycarbonate shell. Travelers appreciate the brand’s built-in USB charging ports and thoughtful interior organization. Reddit discussions often mention that Away suitcases hold up well over time and are worth the investment.
3. Travelpro
For those who fly frequently, Travelpro is a highly recommended brand. Originally designed for airline crews, its luggage is built to withstand heavy use. Reddit users praise its smooth-rolling wheels, lightweight but tough fabric, and expandable compartments. Travelpro’s Platinum Elite and Maxlite series are among the most recommended models.
4. Briggs & Riley
While Briggs & Riley is on the pricier side, many Reddit users say it’s worth every penny. This brand stands out for its lifetime warranty, which covers even airline damage. The luggage is known for its high-quality materials, functional design, and ability to withstand years of travel.
5. Rimowa
For travelers who prioritize luxury and durability, Rimowa is a top choice. Reddit discussions highlight its premium aluminum and polycarbonate shells, making it one of the most durable luggage brands. While expensive, many users find it to be a long-term investment.
So, which luggage brand is the best quality? It depends on your needs and budget, but Samsonite, Away, Travel pro, Briggs & Riley, and Rimowa consistently receive high marks from travelers on Reddit.
Worst Luggage Brands to Avoid
Not all luggage brands live up to expectations. According to Reddit users, some brands suffer from poor durability, unreliable wheels, and weak zippers. Here are some commonly mentioned brands to avoid.
1. Rockland
While Rockland luggage is budget-friendly, many travelers report issues with broken wheels and torn fabric after minimal use. Reddit reviews frequently mention that these suitcases struggle to withstand the rigors of frequent travel.
2. American Tourist
Despite being a popular brand, American Tourist receives mixed reviews. While some users find it decent for occasional trips, others complain about flimsy materials and short lifespans. Many Reddit users suggest avoiding it for long-term use.
3. IT Luggage
Known for its ultra-lightweight designs, IT Luggage often disappoints travelers in terms of durability. Reddit discussions frequently mention bent frames, broken zippers, and weak handles after just a few trips.
4. Amazon Basics
While affordable, Amazon Basics luggage tends to have short-lived wheels and weak handles. Many Reddit users report that the material wears out quickly, making it less reliable for frequent traveler.
Hard vs. Soft Luggage: Which One is Better?
When choosing luggage, travelers often debate between hard-shell and soft-shell suitcases. Each has its own advantages and drawbacks, depending on travel needs, packing preferences, and airline regulations.
Pros and Cons of Hard-Shell Luggage
✅ Durability & Protection – Hard-shell suitcases, usually made from polycarbonate or aluminum, offer excellent protection against impacts. They keep fragile items safer compared to soft luggage.
✅ Water Resistance – Unlike fabric suitcases, hard-shell luggage repels water, keeping belongings dry in rainy conditions.
✅ Security – Most hard-shell luggage has built-in TSA locks, and its rigid structure makes it harder to tamper with.
❌ Less Flexibility – Hard-shell suitcases don’t expand, making it difficult to squeeze in extra items.
❌ Prone to Scratches & Cracks – While durable, hard-shell suitcases can show scratches easily and may crack under extreme pressure.
Which Luggage is Best, Hard or Soft?
It depends on travel style. If protection and security are priorities, hard-shell luggage is a better choice. If flexibility and lightweight design matter more, soft-shell luggage is ideal.
Do Airlines Prefer Hard or Soft Luggage?
Most airlines don’t have a preference, but hard-shell luggage is often better for checked bags due to its durability. However, soft-shell luggage is commonly recommended for carry-ons since it fits more easily into overhead bins.
Luggage Durability & Lifespan
A suitcase should last for years, but its durability depends on materials, construction, and usage. Investing in well-made luggage can prevent the inconvenience of broken handles or busted zippers mid-trip.
What Type of Luggage Lasts Longer?
✔️ Polycarbonate & Aluminum Luggage – These materials are among the most durable. Polycarbonate offers flexibility and impact resistance, while aluminum is tough but heavier.
✔️ Ballistic Nylon – High-quality soft-shell luggage made from ballistic nylon resists tears and abrasions better than polyester.
✔️ Double-Wheel Systems – Suitcases with four multi-directional spinner wheels are more durable than those with two fixed wheels.
What is the Lifespan of Luggage?
Budget Luggage (Low-quality materials): 1-3 years
Mid-Range Luggage (Brands like Samsonite, Travelpro): 5-10 years
Premium Luggage (Briggs & Riley, Rimowa):
10+ years (with proper care)
To extend your luggage’s lifespan, avoid overpacking, store it properly, and clean it after each trip. Choosing quality materials and construction ensures your luggage will withstand years of travel.
Choosing the Right Luggage: Key Features to Look For
Selecting the right luggage is crucial for a hassle-free travel experience. A well-built suitcase should be durable, easy to maneuver, and capable of protecting your belongings. Here are the key features to consider when evaluating luggage quality.
Material & Build Quality
The durability of a suitcase largely depends on its material:
✔️ Hard-shell luggage – Look for polycarbonate or aluminum. These materials offer superior impact resistance and last longer than cheaper ABS plastic.
✔️ Soft-shell luggage – Ballistic nylon or polyester is best. Ballistic nylon is more durable and tear-resistant compared to standard polyester fabric.
How to Know If a Luggage Is Good?
A high-quality suitcase should have a sturdy frame, reinforced stitching, durable zippers, and smooth wheels. Check reviews and brand reputation before making a purchase.
Luggage to Avoid & Recommended Sizes
Not all luggage types are ideal for frequent travelers. Some are poorly designed, less durable, or simply inconvenient for air travel.
Which Luggage Bag Size Is Best?
✔️ Carry-On (20″-22″) – Best for short trips and avoiding baggage fees. Most airlines allow carry-ons within these dimensions.
✔️ Medium Checked Luggage (24″-26″) – Ideal for week-long trips. Provides ample space without exceeding airline weight restrictions.
✔️ Large Checked Luggage (28″-30″) – Suitable for long-term travel but can be difficult to handle due to size and weight limits.
For frequent travelers, a 22″ carry-on and a 25″ checked bag offer the best balance of convenience and capacity.
To know more read also Top Luggage Brands for International Travel
Travel Regulations: Understanding the 3-1-1 Rule
When packing for air travel, it’s essential to follow TSA (Transportation Security Administration) guidelines to avoid delays at security checkpoints. One of the most important regulations for carry-on luggage is the 3-1-1 rule, which applies to liquids, gels, and aerosols.
The rule applies to:
Toiletries (shampoo, toothpaste, lotion, perfume, hairspray)
Drinks & Soups (water, juice, coffee, canned soup)
Liquid Makeup (foundation, mascara, lip gloss)
Gels & Creams (hand sanitizer, sunscreen, shaving cream)
Medications, baby formula, and breast milk are exempt but must be declared at security.
How to Pack Liquids Efficiently
Use travel-sized bottles to avoid wasting space.
Store all liquids in a quart-sized, resealable plastic bag for easy access.
Keep the bag in an easily reachable spot in your carry-on to speed up security checks.
Following the 3-1-1 rule ensures a smooth airport experience and prevents confiscation of items at security.
Is Samsonite a Korean Brand?
No, Samsonite is not a Korean brand. It is an American luggage company with a long history in the travel industry.
A Brief History of Samsonite
Founded in 1910 by Jesse Shwayder in Denver, Colorado, USA.
Originally started as Shwayder Trunk Manufacturing Company, producing sturdy travel trunks.
Rebranded as Samsonite in 1941, inspired by the biblical figure Samson, known for his strength.
Expanded globally, becoming one of the most recognized luggage brands.
Samsonite’s Global Presence
Although Samsonite is an American company, it has manufacturing facilities worldwide, including Europe, Asia, and South America. In 2011, Samsonite acquired Tumi, a luxury luggage brand, further expanding its market.
While South Korea is home to popular brands like HARTMANN (owned by Samsonite) and Kakao Friends luggage, Samsonite itself is not a Korean company.
FAQs for the Blog post: “Best and Worst Luggage Brands on Reddit”:
1. What are the best luggage brands recommended on Reddit?
Reddit users often praise brands like Samsonite, Travelpro, Away, and Rimowa for their durability, design, and value. These brands are frequently recommended for frequent travelers looking for long-lasting suitcases.
2. What are the worst luggage brands according to Reddit?
Based on Reddit discussions, some of the worst-rated luggage brands include It Luggage, Rockland, and certain American Tourister models, which users report as having poor durability, weak zippers, or flimsy handles.
3. How do I choose the best luggage brand for my travel needs?
Redditors suggest considering durability, weight, wheel quality, and warranty when selecting luggage. Hard-shell suitcases from premium brands and soft-shell bags with reinforced corners tend to last longer.
4. Is expensive luggage always better?
Not necessarily! While premium brands like Rimowa or Tumi offer high-quality materials, Reddit users recommend mid-range brands like Travelpro or Samsonite for excellent quality at a lower price.
5. Where can I find Reddit discussions on luggage brands?
You can explore r/travel, r/one bag, and r/BuyIt For Life on Reddit to see real user experiences, reviews, and comparisons of different luggage brands.
Conclusion
Choosing the right luggage can make all the difference in your travel experience. Based on Reddit discussions, we’ve explored the best and worst luggage brands, compared hard vs. soft-shell luggage, and highlighted key features to consider before making a purchase. Durability, materials, zippers, wheels, and customer service are all crucial factors when selecting a suitcase that will last.
To avoid travel headaches, steer clear of brands with frequent complaints about poor build quality, weak zippers, and unreliable wheels. Instead, invest in well-reviewed luggage that meets your travel needs, whether it’s a lightweight carry-on for short trips or a sturdy checked bag for longer adventures.
